Skip to content
HomeBlogTeachingBefore a Colleague Reviews Your Teaching, Agree on What the Review Is For

Before a Colleague Reviews Your Teaching, Agree on What the Review Is For

A colleague offers to visit your class, and you say yes. Later you realize you haven't discussed whether the visit is informal feedback, part of a required evaluation, or both. That uncertainty can change how each of you understands the conversation.

The handbook describes peer review as a source of teaching evidence and professional learning. Begin by making the purpose and process clear.

Identify the kind of review

Check whether the activity is a developmental exchange, a formal review, or another defined process. Learn the requirements for your situation, including reviewer selection, materials, timing, and use of the resulting record.

Don't assume a friendly conversation and a personnel-review document follow the same rules.

Choose a useful focus

You might want feedback on an explanation, discussion pattern, assignment sequence, or another aspect of the course. For a formal review, use the required criteria. Explain any additional question within the process that applies.

A defined focus gives the reviewer something more useful to examine than whether the class felt generally successful.

Provide appropriate context

Explain the course level, learning goals, place in the sequence, and relevant teaching decisions. Identify the permitted materials that can help the reviewer understand the lesson or course.

Context should support interpretation without supplying a preferred conclusion.

Clarify the evidence and its limits

A class observation, course materials, feedback, and other records show different things. Agree on what will be examined and how it relates to the purpose. One lesson offers a limited view of a larger teaching record.

Ask for observations and reasoning that distinguish what was seen from what is inferred.

Plan the conversation and follow-through

Confirm how feedback will be discussed, documented, and used. Follow the relevant confidentiality and access rules. Decide how you'll identify a practical next step after receiving the response.

A useful review can recognize strengths and reveal a question that needs more evidence. It doesn't have to produce an instant solution to every teaching problem.

Keep the feedback question within the review's purpose

If the review is meant to examine a particular part of teaching, explain why that part matters and what evidence is available. A question about students' use of feedback may need assignment materials and examples of the sequence, while a question about discussion may need observation of the interaction.

Don't ask a reviewer to infer an entire course's effectiveness from evidence that supports only a narrower account. A useful report can identify what was examined, what was observed, and what further information would be needed for a broader judgment.

After the review, distinguish a suggestion from a required finding or action under the applicable process. Ask for clarification when the wording leaves that uncertain. Then choose a reasonable next step and the evidence that will help you examine it. Clear expectations before the review make the follow-through more useful, because both people understand what the feedback was intended to address and how the record may be used.

Before scheduling the next review, write down its purpose, focus, materials, and use of the report. Confirm that understanding with the appropriate people. You'll have a clearer basis for both the observation and the learning that follows.

Share this article

Weekly email

New articles in your inbox every Monday

One short email a week with the newest CVfolder articles, for everyone with a CVfolder account. Sent only when there is something new; switch it off any time.

Keep your evidence ready

Build an academic portfolio for your next review. It's free.

Get started